Desperation Morale

Contact

  • World of ASL
  • Play Aids
  • Scenarios
  • ASL Museum
  • Misc
  • Blog
Home > Products > CH Annual Issue 2

03.2016 CH Annual Issue 2

Alternative Titles/Edition History:
CONSUMER ALERT

aka Critical Hit Annual Issue 2

Publisher/Date:
Critical Hit (2015)

Product Type:
Periodical

Country of Origin:
U.S.A.

Contents:
48-page magazine, 4 11" x 16" unmounted (on thick paper/thin cardstock) geoboards (AA, BB, CC, DD), 8 scenarios (as pages of magazine), 1 Platoon Leader campaign game (for Berlin modules), Berlin SASL rules, 5 SASL campaign games, 5 SASL missions, 280 1/2" diecut counters

Commentary:

This product gets a Desperation Morale CONSUMER ALERT.

However, first an admission. In its write-up of CH Annual Number 1, Critical Hit’s attempt to resurrect its old Critical Hit Magazine, Desperation Morale wrote:

The first thing you can be sure of is that it is unlikely to actually be released annually–if there indeed is ever a second issue (Critical Hit has had a history of starting “series” that never survived past item #1 in the series).

Well, we were right and we were wrong.  The next issue of CH Annual actually occurred in the same year as the first issue–2015–rendering it distinctly un-annualish.  On the other hand, Critical Hit actually did get a second issue out, making it the relatively rare CH “series” product to go past #1.

However, once one examines CH Annual Issue 2 (hereinafter CHA2), it becomes more understandable how a second issue was able to come out relatively quickly.  CHA1 was basically a compilation of various odds and ends from the back of the CH file cabinets; CHA2 clearly is as well.

CHA2 takes the format of a 48-page magazine, but actual magazine content is rather thin.  As with the first issue, CH principal Ray Tapio took various e-mails sent to him and published him in the Annual as “letters to the editor” (something that anybody thinking of e-mailing them should keep in mind).  The only “articles” in the magazine are two separate write-ups of the same playing of CH’s Berlin modules at a Texas tournament.  The rest of the publication is taken up by scenarios and rules (see below).  It should be noted that the physical quality of the magazine is relatively poor.  Though it is in color, there is a swathe of ink smudge that runs across every page at about the same place (clearly a problem with the printing press).

Most of the product’s content centers on Berlin, thanks to the popularity of Critical Hit’s two variously-titled Berlin historical modules (they have gone through so many name changes that even Critical Hit now refers to them as the “Berlin modules” or generically as Berlin 1 and Berlin 2).  Though large and complex and never quite fully developed, the Berlin modules have an attraction for certain ASLers, thanks in no small part to the large and interesting historical maps.

The first bit of Berlin content is a new campaign game that uses both Berlin 1 and Berlin 2 and is more extensive than the the previous combo campaign game, CGIV (The Downfall).  The first editions of both Berlin modules each contained two campaign games, but those were stripped from subsequent releases for unknown reasons.  The new campaign game is called CGV Sector Z, which is not very catchy.  This campaign game is credited in the magazine to Edo Benvento, which raises questions about its nature and provenance.  Edo, a long-time fan of campaign games and defender of Critical Hit, was working on a big Berlin campaign game for Critical Hit but in 2014 finally had enough of Critical Hit and broke with them (saying “that bridge with CH was not merely burned, it was blown apart.”  So did Edo have a change of heart, finish a campaign game, and allow Critical Hit to print it in CHA2?  Or did Ray Tapio publish an unfinished version of the campaign game materials?  Everything is murky.

The second part of the Berlin bonanza is a large SASL (i.e., Solitaire ASL) project using the Berlin components created by Jörgen Holmquist, a Swedish ASLer and long-time fan of SASL.  Ray Tapio includes a disclaimer, “Jorgen [sic] continues to develop his solo rules…Needless to say, this material is considered experimental, with a mutual interest assumed; it is not for those needing hand-holding, but instead for the curious, desiring a framework to game the Battle of Berlin.”  This is basically Rayspeak for “I did not develop or playtest these rules, so you are on your own.” Desperation Morale contacted Holmquist to learn more and discovered that the SASL materials sent to Ray were not a finished product: they were incomplete and needed more work and testing. Moreover, Ray Tapio did not consult with Holmquist before publishing the unfinished project.

The premature publication of these Berlin SASL materials is certainly unfortunate, because they seem like an interesting project.  They include of 5 different campaign games:  BFDCG-1 (Götterdämmerung in Berlin), BFDCG-2 (Race to the Reichstag), BFDCG-3 (In the Ruins of the Reich), BFDCG-4 (The Downfall) and BFDCG-5 (Sector Z).  The project also includes 5 missions: BFDX1 (Until the Bitter End), BFDX2 (Counterattack in the Embassy Ruins), BFDX3 (Desperate Resistance in the Moabit District), BFDX4 (Among the Ruins), and BFDX5 (The Downfall).  This should be a warning to anybody thinking about possibly working with Critical Hit.

The third Berlin item in CHA2 are the “Berlin Geo” scenarios.  CHA2 comes with 4 Gary Fortenberry-style 11″ x 16″ geoboards.  Two of these, boards CC and DD are not typical geoboards but are essentially designed to mimic or resemble the artwork style of CH’s Berlin modules.  This is a little bizarre and hard to explain, so stay with us here. These two boards, which mate with each other (more or less) but not with any other boards, essentially take a portion of one of the Berlin 2 maps and sort of recreate that portion on the two geoboards.  Note that this is NOT the artwork from the Berlin modules, nor does it actually reproduce that map area exactly–it is a sort of strange approximation of the art style and the terrain.  So, for example, there is a prominent building on the Berlin map (the Reichstag building, actually) that is represented on map DD–only the map DD version is slightly smaller.  Why?  It is not at all clear.  Some things on the map are the same size as in the originals but others are not.  Of the Reichstag building, Ray Tapio writes:  “Note that the geo-board rendition of this building is reduced, in keeping with the geo-approach to buildings in general.”  What??  One cannot help but be reminded of the movie Spinal Tap, when members of the ban find that their requested recreation of Stonehenge is only a fraction of the intended size.

The “Geo Rules” are three pages of simplified Berlin rules so that players can play four included Berlin scenarios on the pseudo-Berlin geoboards.  The scenarios, by the way, do not come on scenario cards, but must be photocopied, scanned, or cut out from the magazine itself.   God only knows what sort of Frankensteins the scenarios are.  For example, CHA13 (Fly the Red Banner) seems to be loosely based on the scenario Raise the Red Banner from Berlin: Fall of the Third Reich.  It contains the exact same historical description and the OBs have a vague resemblance to each other.  The other three scenarios seem similarly cobbled together.  The whole thing certainly seems suspicious.

The included countersheet contains infantry counters for use with these four scenarios; these are counters that appeared in the Berlin modules, mostly duplicates of existing counters but with some new units as well.

The other four scenarios included in CHA2, which use the other two geoboards, AA and BB, are Normandy scenarios.   In an amazing bit of effrontery–but one that should not surprise anyone familiar with the, ahem, integrity of Critical Hit–some of these scenarios appear to be cribbed/stolen/plagiarized/borrowed (take your pick, depending on how charitable you are) from a previous publisher, the French magazine Tactiques.

Scenario CHA14 (Purple Heart Road), for example,  bears an uncanny resemblance to TAC47 (Roses for Vandervoort) in its OB, victory conditions, and even historical description.   What are the odds that an American scenario designer would come up with a scenario so eerily similar to this older design published in France–but which has an English translation widely available on the web?

Similarly, CHA15 (Fritz’s Escape) is a modified but still ripped-off version of TAC48 (Trapped).  And CHA16 (Peregory’s Push) is nothing more than a transbobulated version of TAC58 (29 Let’s Go).

It is not immediately clear if CHA16 (Hill 192) was similarly “re-imagined” from some previously published scenario or not, but, based on the other three, it would not be surprising if it were.

One can almost imagine the gears clinking and clanking at Critical Hit.  Why Tactiques?  Well, it is long since defunct, and it is from France, so the odds of anybody suing are pretty low.  Moreover, clink clank, someone translated those scenarios into English and put them on the web, clank clink, so what if it could be argued that they were now somehow “public domain.”  Clank clink clank.  Of course, the moral and ethical questions of appropriating someone else’s ideas and work does not seem to have been considered–as Critical Hit has demonstrated several other times in the recent past.   For shame.

For all of this mish-mash and questionable ethics, Critical Hit is trying to charge customers $79.95.  For a magazine.  For THIS magazine.  This product gets a Desperation Morale CONSUMER ALERT.

Back to Top

Tagged: Campaign Game(s), City-Fighting, CONSUMER ALERT, East Front-oriented, Gary-style geoboards, Magazine, Platoon Leader Campaign Game(s), SASL, Third Party Geoboard(s)

Comments

  1. Vincent Maresca says

    March 20, 2016 at 12:10 pm

    Mark – the Berlin material appears to be “based on” Coastal Fortress’ “To the Reichstag! Mini-Campaign” originally published by Tactiques and would fit the “theme” of the magazine.

    Reply

Leave A Reply Cancel reply

Search Site

All Categories

  • ASL Newsletters
    • Newsletters with Scenarios
    • Newsletters without Scenarios
  • Avalon Hill Products
  • MMP Products
    • Unofficial Periodicals
  • Official Publishers (Avalon Hill & MMP)
    • "Core" Modules
    • Accessories
    • Foreign Language ASL
    • Miniatures
    • Non-WWII Expansion Modules
    • Official ASL Starter Kit Products
    • Official DASL Modules
    • Official Historical Modules
    • Official Mini-Scenario/Map Pack
    • Official Periodicals
    • Official Rulebooks
    • Official Scenario & Scenario/Map Packs
    • Official Software & On-Line Products
    • Official Solitaire ASL (SASL)
  • Third Party Publishers
    • Abdicated Despot Company
      • Periodicals
    • Action Terrain
      • Accessories
    • Advancing Fire
      • Historical Modules
    • ASL Cards
      • Accessories
    • ASL News
      • Periodicals
    • ASL Sweden
      • Periodicals
    • Battleschool
      • Accessories
    • Bill Wilder/First to Fight Variants
      • Counter Supplement
      • Scenario Packs
      • Solitaire Rules
    • Bounding Fire Productions
      • Historical Modules
      • Scenario & Scenario/Map Packs
    • Break Contact
      • Scenario Packs
    • Broken Ground Design
      • Counter Sets
      • Mini-Scenario/Map Packs
    • Countersmith Workshop
      • Accessories
    • Critical Hit
      • Accessories
      • Campaign Games
      • Counter Packs/Counter Sets
      • Historical Modules
      • Map Packs (no scenarios)
      • Periodicals
      • Rulebooks
      • Scenario & Scenario/Map Packs
    • Dare-Death
      • Periodicals
    • Derek Ritter
      • Accessories
    • Desperation Morale
      • Manuals
    • EastSide Gamers
      • Scenario Packs
      • Zombie Stuff
    • ELR
      • Scenario Packs
    • Encircled Productions/Kansas City Irregular ASLers
      • Scenario Packs
    • Fanatic Enterprises
      • Accessories
      • Scenario & Scenario/Map Packs
    • Flying Pig Games
      • Periodicals
    • Friendly Fire
      • Friendly Fire Scenario Packs
    • Front Line Productions
      • Historical Modules
    • Heat of Battle
      • Historical Modules
      • Periodicals
      • Scenario & Scenario/Map Packs
    • JagerSoft Games LLC
      • Historical Modules
    • Kinetic Energy
      • Counter Pack
      • Periodicals
      • Scenario Packs
    • Le Franc Tireur
      • Accessories
      • Historical Modules
      • Periodicals
      • Scenario & Scenario/Map Packs
    • Lone Canuck Publishing
      • Historical Modules
      • Scenario Packs
    • Minden Games
      • Rulebooks
    • Mister T
      • Accessories
    • New England Volunteers
      • Scenario Packs
    • New England Volunteers & Yankee ASL
      • Scenario Packs
    • North Texas ASL
      • Scenario Packs
    • Panzer Press
      • Scenario Packs
    • Partisan Publishing
      • Scenario Packs
    • Sherry Enterprises (Schwerpunkt)
      • Periodicals
      • Scenario Packs
    • Southern California ASL Club
      • Periodicals
      • Scenario Packs
    • Southern Cross
      • Scenario Packs
    • Stavka Archives
      • Scenario Packs
    • Struijf-Mazzei (Death to Fascism)
      • Scenario Packs
    • Swedish Volunteers
      • Scenario Pack
    • Tactiques
      • Periodicals
    • Taktyka I Strategia
      • Periodicals
    • Texas ASL Club
      • Periodicals
      • Scenario Packs
    • The Tactical Wargamer
      • Periodicals
    • View from the Trenches
      • Campaign Games
      • Periodicals
      • Scenario Packs
    • War-Oboe Publications
      • Scenario Packs
    • Windy City Wargamers
      • Periodicals
      • Scenario Packs
    • Winnipeg ASL Club
      • Periodicals
      • Scenario Packs
  • Wargaming Magazines with ASL Scenarios

All Tags

  • A Bridge Too Far material
  • Action Pack
  • Advanced
  • Afrika Korps Series
  • AFV Cards
  • Airdrop/Glider
  • Alternative Counter Color Scheme
  • Alternative Map System
  • Alternative Rules System
  • Alternative Use of HASL Map
  • Amphibious
  • Arab-Israeli Wars
  • ASLSK
  • Battle of the Bulge
  • Blood Reef Tarawa materials
  • Bonus Pack
  • Burma
  • Campaign Game(s)
  • Chaco War
  • Chapter H Pages
  • Chinese Civil War
  • Chinese-language
  • City-Fighting
  • CONSUMER ALERT
  • Contains material for Hatten in Flames
  • Counterfactual/Fictional Scenario(s)
  • Critical Hit Normandy Series
  • CWASL
  • DASL
  • DASL Boards
  • Desert War: 1941 series
  • Desert-Oriented
  • Design-Your-Own
  • Dice
  • Digital
  • DM High Recommendation
  • Downloadable
  • Dutch-language
  • East Front-oriented
  • Exceedingly Rare Shit
  • Extra Stuff for 3rd Party HASL
  • Extra Stuff for Official HASL
  • Extra-Large Counters
  • Festung Budapest materials
  • Fog of War Scenarios
  • France 1940
  • French Language
  • Gary-style geoboards
  • Genesis III series
  • Geoboard Campaign Game(s)
  • God Save the King materials
  • GWASL
  • historical
  • Historical Map(s)
  • Indochina-Vietnam Wars
  • Introductory
  • Irish Wars
  • Italian-language
  • Italo-Ethiopian War
  • Japanese-language
  • Kakazu Ridge materials
  • Kampfgruppe Peiper materials
  • King of the Hill materials
  • Korean War
  • Kursk
  • Linked-Scenario Campaign Game
  • Magazine
  • Manuals
  • Market-Garden
  • mini-HASL
  • Miniatures
  • Misc Conflicts 1920-1929
  • Misc Conflicts 1930-1939
  • Misc Conflicts 1941-1955
  • Misc Conflicts 1956+
  • Misc Conflicts Pre-1920
  • Module-Specific Manual/Guide
  • Monster Historical Scenario
  • Monster Product
  • Newsletter
  • Nhpum Ga materials
  • Nomanhan
  • Non-DASL Large Hex Map/Board
  • Non-Geomorphic Generic Maps
  • Non-historical/contemporary map
  • Nonstandard Geoboards
  • Normandy
  • Official Geoboards
  • Official Overlays
  • Official Rules Pages
  • Operation Veritable materials
  • Operational Subsystem
  • Partially-geomorphic board(s)
  • PBDYO
  • Pegasus Bridge materials
  • Platoon Leader Campaign Game(s)
  • Polish-language
  • Postwar Anti-communist Partisans
  • PTO-Oriented
  • Rare Vehicles
  • Recon Leader
  • Red Barricades materials
  • Requires GWASL components
  • Russian Civil War
  • Russo-Polish War
  • SASL
  • Satire
  • Software
  • Spanish Civil War
  • Spanish-language
  • Squad Leader Scenario Conversions
  • Stalingrad
  • Strategy Manual
  • Third Party Counters (Not CH)
  • Third Party Geoboard(s)
  • Third Party Overlay(s)
  • Three Player Scenario
  • To the Volga series
  • Tournament Friendly
  • Tournament Prize Pack
  • Unit Study
  • Uses ASLN1 Geoboard from ASL News
  • uses aslsk
  • Uses ASLSK geoboard(s)
  • Uses Berlin Fall of the Third Reich Components
  • Uses Beyond the Beachhead 2 boards
  • Uses Beyond the Beachhead 2 rules
  • Uses Beyond the Beachhead components
  • Uses BFP A geoboard from Into the Rubble
  • Uses BFP H geoboard from High Ground 2
  • Uses BFP I geoboard from High Ground 2
  • Uses BFP J geoboard from High Ground 2
  • Uses BFP M geoboard from Crucible of Steel
  • Uses BFP N geoboard from Crucible of Steel
  • Uses BFP-B geoboard from Into the Rubble
  • Uses Blitzkrieg in the West: North Campaign components
  • Uses Blood and Jungle counters
  • Uses CH W# Boards from Fire and Ice
  • Uses CH1 geoboard from Gembloux II
  • Uses CH2 geoboard from A Few Rare Men
  • Uses Chosin/Chosin Few Components
  • Uses components from Forgotten War
  • Uses Components from Kampfgruppe Scherer
  • Uses components from Poland in Flames
  • Uses counters from Poland in Flames
  • Uses Critical Hit Afrika Korps Map(s)
  • Uses DASL geoboards from LFT's Deluxe Pack #1
  • Uses Desert War: 1941 components
  • Uses DW-1a/1b geoboard(s) from Blood and Jungle
  • Uses FE1 geoboard from Budapest Pack
  • Uses Festung Budapest map
  • Uses Festung Budapest rules
  • Uses Finland at War Counters
  • Uses Forgotten War components
  • Uses Friendly Fire Geoboard
  • Uses geoboards from Blood and Jungle
  • Uses geoboards from Crucible of Steel
  • Uses geoboards from Deluxe Pack #1
  • Uses geoboards from High Ground 2
  • Uses geoboards from Into the Rubble
  • Uses geoboards from Into the Rubble 2
  • Uses Guerra Civil Components
  • Uses High Ground geoboard(s)
  • Uses Into the Rubble overlays
  • Uses Into the Rubble rules
  • Uses Kampfgruppe Peiper I Map
  • Uses Kampfgruppe Peiper II Map
  • Uses Kampfgruppe Peiper rules
  • Uses Kursk: Devil's Domain maps
  • Uses LFT1 geoboard from LFT11
  • Uses LFT2 geoboard from LFT12
  • Uses Nhpum Ga map
  • Uses Operation Cobra counters
  • Uses Operation Merkur components
  • Uses Operation Veritable map
  • Uses Pegasus Bridge map
  • Uses Pegasus Bridge rules
  • Uses Recon by Fire #4 counters
  • Uses Red Barricades map
  • Uses Red Barricades rules
  • Uses Red October/Red Factories components
  • Uses SCW2 geoboard from Condor Legions
  • Uses Special Forces! counters
  • Uses St. Nazaire map from St. Nazaire
  • Uses Swedish Volunteers components
  • Uses Sweet 16 geoboards from CH
  • Uses Sweet 16 Winter geoboards from CH
  • Uses Total Axis Pack I Components
  • uses Valor of the Guards counters
  • Uses Valor of the Guards map
  • Uses Valor of the Guards rules
  • Valor of the Guards materials
  • winterized
  • Winterized Boards/Maps
  • Zombies

World of ASL

  • World of ASL Main Page
  • This Year's Releases
  • Avalon Hill Products
  • MMP Products
  • Third Party Publishers (all)
  • Recommended

Play Aids

  • Mini-IFT and Setup Sheets
  • Reminders/Checklists
  • Terrain Related
  • Subject Specific
  • HASL Aids
  • AFV Aids
  • SW Aids
  • OBA Decks
  • Sniper Reminders
  • Contributor Section

Scenarios

  • WCW Scenario Pack
  • Michicon Scenarios
  • Tactiques Scenarios
  • Southern Cross Scenarios
  • Gun Duel Scenarios
  • Sir Roger Mercenario

ASL Museum

  • Dice Towers/Cups
  • Rulebooks
  • Counter Storage
  • Play Aids
  • Clothing
  • Mapboards
  • Miniatures
  • Prizes/Trophies
  • Travel Kits
  • Misc.

Misc

  • About this Site
  • Scenario Designers Guide

Blog

  • Quality in ASL: A Reconnaissance in Force
  • ASL and the Pandemic: Social Responsibility and Board Wargaming
  • ASL Gear and the Systainer System: An Introduction
  • The Top 20 ASL Communities by Country
  • World of ASL major update

Contact

  • I welcome all comments & feedback.